Is the Stock Market in a Bubble? Don’t Bet on It.

August’s jobs study was a disappointment. But it didn’t mean each that overmuch to the banal market.

Paul Hennessy/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images

But excavation a small deeper, and each was not arsenic it seemed. The 0.6% month-over-month summation successful mean hourly net pointed to continued inflation, portion the upward revisions to June and July employment numbers, which went to 976,000 and 1.1 million, respectively, suggested that possibly the figures weren’t rather arsenic anemic arsenic they looked. That conscionable astir nary jobs were created successful the leisure and hospitality manufacture indicated that the Covid-19 Delta variant mightiness person been a spot of a problem.

By the extremity of the day, it didn’t look to mean each that overmuch arsenic the S&P 500 closed down 1.52 points connected the day, ending the week astatine 4,535. Still, the jobs study was held up arsenic either a motion of occupation up oregon a awesome that there’s thing to interest about. The numbers could beryllium a reason, successful different words, for the Fed to beryllium cautious connected the commencement of tapering oregon a awesome that the cardinal slope should commencement paring its bond-buying ASAP. “People volition find information to enactment their narrative,” says Hedgeye’s Keith McCullough.

But which narrative? These days, it tin consciousness intolerable to choose, which is, I suppose, wherefore Morgan Stanley strategist Mike Wilson laid retired 2 opposing views successful a enactment released this past week. On the 1 hand, the Fed looks astatine the incoming data, peculiarly connected ostentation and the imaginable for peaking Delta variant cases, and decides it’s clip to taper. Wilson suspects that Jerome Powell & Co. could commencement the process by winter, and erstwhile it does, involvement rates would rise, banal valuations would fall, and the marketplace would driblet 10%, adjacent though fiscal shares could benefit.

On the different hand, a maturation slowdown could besides beryllium successful the offing owed to sagging user assurance and the information that truthful overmuch request has been pulled forward. And if maturation surprises excessively overmuch to the downside, it excessively could origin the marketplace to yet correct, thing that would origin healthcare and consumer-staples stocks to outperform.

“Bottom line, this autumn we inactive expect our midcycle modulation to extremity with a 10%+ S&P 500 correction, but a communicative of either occurrence oregon crystal volition find the leadership,” Wilson writes. “As such, our proposal is simply a barbell of antiaircraft prime with financials to enactment and support successful either scenario, which look arsenic apt to occur.”

Wilson’s fire-and-ice scenarios extremity the aforesaid way, with a long-overdue correction. That a correction should person happened by present is different communicative being bandied astir by investors marveling astatine the market’s nonstop gains. The S&P 500 roseate 2.9% successful August, its seventh consecutive monthly advance, conscionable the 15th clip this has occurred since 1950. It has besides gone each twelvemonth without a driblet of astatine slightest 5%, which has happened conscionable doubly since 1980—in 1995 and 2017—notes Keith Lerner, main marketplace strategist for Truist Advisory Services.

That surely is rare, and there’s nary shortage of reasons that the marketplace should drop. It’s been going up excessively long. It’s excessively expensive. The Fed is distorting its performance.

DataTrek’s Nicholas Colas offered 10 specified rationales, ranging from marketplace seasonality to geopolitical events to a Covid breakout truthful terrible that caller lockdowns are needed. He adjacent cites factors that would payment america successful the existent world, but not needfully the market, specified arsenic a quicker extremity to the pandemic. “Today’s database is not a informing to ‘sell everything,’ ” Colas writes. “Rather, it is simply a (hopefully) broad look astatine what could spell wrong.”

Just due to the fact that it tin spell incorrect doesn’t mean it will. That’s peculiarly existent due to the fact that of the unusual marketplace dynamics astatine play.

J.P. Morgan strategist Nikolaos Panigirtzoglou credits retail investors for overmuch of the rally, buying stocks astatine each dip. But that has pushed equities to levels that has made nonrecreational investors, specified arsenic pension funds, uncomfortable. Rather than loading up connected shares, they’ve bought bonds to support their plus allocations decently weighted. And erstwhile the clip comes, they’ll commencement selling their stocks—and apt their bonds, too—Panigirtzoglou adds.

Still, contempt allocations to stocks for non-bank investors that are present nearing the post–Lehman Brothers high, helium isn’t predicting a correction conscionable yet. “[In] the lack of a worldly slowing successful the retail travel into equities, the hazard of an equity correction remains low,” Panigirtzoglou writes. “Whether the coming Fed argumentation alteration changes retail investors’ cognition towards equities remains to beryllium seen.”

Don’t get maine wrong. No marketplace goes up forever, and this 1 could usage a breather. In this abstraction astatine the extremity of 2020, I pondered whether the banal marketplace was a bubble and concluded it wasn’t, contempt runaway special-acquisition vehicles, blistery archetypal nationalist offerings, and parabolic moves successful galore torrid maturation stocks. Now I’m not truthful sure. But there’s a occupation with trying to foretell a correction: not getting one. The S&P 500 has had 4 drops of 3% oregon much successful 2021, but has resumed its beforehand each time. Selling astatine the bottommost of each would person meant leaving large gains connected the table. Rather than trying to perfectly clip the exit, I’d perceive to the market, which shows nary inclination of correcting conscionable yet.

Remember, you tin archer the marketplace what to do. It conscionable doesn’t person to listen.

Write to Ben Levisohn astatine Ben.Levisohn@barrons.com